A and A's Movie A Day

Watching movies until we run out.

Movie 504 – Close Encounters of the Third Kind

Close Encounters of the Third Kind – July 17th, 2011

Tonight we went looking for a longer movie, something over two hours since we had the time. None of the things we hadn’t seen yet appealed but as soon as I saw this on the list I knew it was right for tonight. And so the mad search commenced! Our apartment isn’t that big and we do own a lot of movies and they’re not as organized as we’d like. And we could not find this. Andy searched every stack in every room and it was nowhere to be found. I said I’d look, moved one Simpsons box set out of the way and there it was. I’ll give Andy a pass, though, because it’s one of the ones we bought cheap and it has no actual case, just a plastic sleeve with the disc and the cover and it was stuck to another disc in another plastic sleeve. And you know, I’m really glad I found it because it was precisely what I wanted tonight and I would have been so bummed to have to pick something else.

Within science fiction there are a number of sub-genres. The “aliens come to Earth” idea is one of those sub-genres and it’s an interesting one. It can take place present-day without trying to envision a future for humanity and it provides a whole host of possibilities. Are the aliens friendly or hostile? Do they understand us and can we understand them? What do they want, if anything? What do they look like? Do we even see them? What I like about this movie is that it is so largely grounded not in space but on Earth. It’s about the reactions people have to this unexplained thing that’s happened to them and the people they know. In the end the aliens themselves aren’t so much the point. The point is in the connection and the discovery and the journey and events that lead to them.

When the movie starts strange things are happening. Fighter planes reported missing in 1945 appear in the Sonora Desert thirty years late, missing their pilots. A man nearby says the sun came out at night and sang to him. Air traffic controllers call in reports of something mysterious in the sky, then decline to make any official reports. And in Muncie, Indiana a boy wakes up when all of his toys turn on, only to find the fridge’s contents on the kitchen floor. He walks out of the house, into the night. Elsewhere in town, while the boy’s mother chases him into the woods, another family is arguing over what to do the next night. Their father heads out to help repair some power outages and finds himself having a very strange experience with bright lights and his truck going haywire. It’s all the beginning of a number of mysterious events, with electrical oddities and bright lights in the sky and the strange return of vehicles long missing.

But the bulk of the movie is spent with Roy Neary, the man who left his family to go help with the power outages, and Jillian Guiler, whose son Barry is taken by the aliens mid-movie. We see the two of them struggle with this experience they’ve both had, unable to explain what they’ve seen and unable to convince their families or the public that whatever happened actually happened. Now, in a movie made today? Roy and Jillian would end up in love and half the movie would be a romantic plotline for them. I am pleased to say that this doesn’t happen here. Not really. The two of them bond through the shared knowledge that what they saw was real, but there’s no epic love story being attempted between the two of them. Just the story of two people who’ve been separated from the norm by experiences they didn’t want in the first place.

Now, I do have some quibbles with the movie, in that we learn very little about Jillian’s life aside from that she’s a mother and apparently it’s just her and her son? And on the other hand we learn plenty about Roy’s family and they’re presented as both thoroughly annoying and completely justified in being frustrated by him. After all, he starts out as a somewhat uninvested father, spreading his stuff all over the obviously too-small house, much to the frustration of his wife. He goes out overnight for work, is unreachable all night leading to middle-of-the-night phone calls at his house, waking his wife and kids. And when he comes back he’s ranting and raving about lights in the sky and flying saucers. He becomes thoroughly obsessed and you can tell that not only is he frustrated and confused by it all, but his wife and children are all of that as well as scared. To them it probably seems as though Roy’s had a mental break of some sort. But there’s no resolution there. The wife and kids head off to the wife’s sister’s place, leaving Roy on his own to build a model of the Devil’s Tower in the middle of their kitchen. And I’m left wondering how we’re meant to feel about the family.

In the end Roy leaves with the aliens without a second thought, or so it seems. But what happens to that family? Those kids? They’re not bad people and they’re not portrayed as such, just crowded and loud. And now their father is gone. Not just absent, but off the planet. Much as I love the introduction of the alien spaceship near the end, with the iconic music playing in greeting and all, and much as I want to see the whole thing at the end where they choose Roy as a positive note, I can’t. It’s not as if his family was taken from him. It’s not as if they’re gone for good. And I can’t really see a character who’d walk away from his family after putting them through what Roy puts them through, leaving them likely never to know what happened to him, as someone to fully sympathize with. I want to! I really do! Because if you take away the family stuff Roy’s experience is amazing and wonderful. Put the family stuff in and I’m conflicted about him.

All that being said, the ending to this movie is one of my favorite movie endings ever. After the build-up for the aliens, with the tiny ships zipping by, bright and indistinct, the huge ship coming in to blare its music at everyone is fantastic. The return of the missing pilots and Navy officers? Gets me every time. There’s a touch of this in Flight of the Navigator, which explores more about what would happen when one of those abductees returns after so long away. I love it, cheesy alien costumes and all. I love the set-up, with the government knowing that this is going on the whole time and having people trained for the eventuality of being taken by aliens. I love that Jillian decides not to go but is still clearly enthralled by it, just like her son is after he’s been returned. It’s an excellent climax to a mostly excellent movie

July 17, 2011 - Posted by | daily reviews | , , ,

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: